Philosophy of Chemistry: Matter, Transformation, and Practices
Call for Papers
Philosophy of Chemistry: Matter, Transformation, and Practices
Transversal: International Journal for the Historiography of Science will receive proposals for articles in the Philosophy of Chemistry, in its historical, conceptual, and historiographical dimensions, for the issue of December 2027.
For much of the twentieth century, philosophy of science took physics as its paradigm of scientificity and treated chemistry as an applied chapter of quantum mechanics. Since the 1990s, this picture has changed steadily. The philosophy of chemistry has established itself as a field in its own right, with specialized journals (HYLE, since 1995; Foundations of Chemistry, since 1999), an international society (the International Society for the Philosophy of Chemistry, which has met annually since the late 1990s), a volume of the Handbook of the Philosophy of Science (2012), and, more recently, a dedicated series in the Cambridge Elements. The field no longer needs to claim legitimacy; it now formulates, in its own voice, problems that concern the philosophy of science as a whole.
The starting point of this call is not to use chemistry to illustrate general theses – deductivism, inductivism, realism, anti-realism, constructivism – but to ask what chemistry, as the science of substances and their transformations, offers philosophers as an object of inquiry. Chemistry has a distinctive feature: it produces a large share of the objects it studies. This synthetic vocation, constantly put to the test in the confrontation between laboratory practices and the theories chemists devise to explain phenomena or to suggest new compositions, unsettles the classical boundary between the natural and the artificial, between knowing and making.
At the ontological level, contemporary debates question the status of chemical entities: whether elements and substances are natural kinds; whether chemical identity is defined by microstructure (“Is water H₂O?”); whether molecular structure is reducible to the quantum-mechanical description or chemistry enjoys ontological autonomy; and to what extent relational and process ontologies better account for a matter defined by its transformations. Mereology reopens an old problem, that of the relation between the whole and its parts, which historically set the advocates of the juxtaposition of corpuscles against the defenders of Aristotelian mixis and scholastic mixtio – a debate Duhem took up again in Le mixte et la combinaison chimique (1902).
At the epistemological and methodological level, attention turns to analysis and synthesis, experimentation and instrumentation, classification systems and the periodic system, nomenclatures and chemical language. Structural formulas, material and computational models, and reaction mechanisms also call for semiotic analysis. The growing use of machine learning to predict new substances and reaction mechanisms now raises unprecedented questions about prediction, explanation, and understanding in chemistry. Finally, the ubiquity of chemical products in human societies and in the environment – from diffuse toxicity to green chemistry and the debates on the Anthropocene – calls for ethical, political, and aesthetic reflection.
Chemistry, however, was an object of philosophical reflection long before a “philosophy of chemistry” existed as a discipline. The alchemical and Paracelsian traditions, the chemical philosophies of van Helmont, Bacon, and Boyle, Venel’s article “Chymie” in the Encyclopédie, Lavoisier’s chemistry, Kant’s reservations about the scientific status of chemistry, Hegel’s “chemism”, and, in the twentieth century, the reflections of Duhem, Meyerson, Paneth, and Bachelard constitute a conceptual heritage that remains largely underexplored. Likewise, historiographical narratives – such as the “Chemical Revolution”, the separation between alchemy and chemistry, and the subordination of chemistry to physics – have shaped the philosophical images of chemistry and deserve to be examined in their own right. A journal devoted to the historiography of science is a privileged venue for bringing these two fronts together.
For this dossier, we invite researchers to submit contributions in the philosophy of chemistry from historical, analytical, or historiographical perspectives, and especially work that brings these perspectives into dialogue. Submissions addressing the following topics, among others, are welcome:
- Ontology of chemistry: elements, substances, chemical species, natural kinds, and chemical identity;
- Reduction, emergence, and the relations between chemistry and physics (molecular structure, the chemical bond, quantum chemistry);
- Relational and process ontologies of matter and chemical transformation;
- Mereology, composition, and mixture: from Aristotelian mixis to contemporary theories;
- Epistemology and methodology of chemistry: analysis and synthesis, experimentation, instrumentation, and simulation;
- Language, representation, and models: formulas, nomenclatures, material and computational models;
- Chemical classifications and the periodic system;
- Chemistry and artificial intelligence: prediction, explanation, and understanding;
- Ethics, politics, and aesthetics of chemistry: synthesis and responsibility, toxicity, green chemistry, the environment, and the Anthropocene;
- Chemistry in the history of philosophy: alchemy, chemical philosophies of the sixteenth to eighteenth centuries, the Enlightenment, nineteenth- and twentieth-century traditions;
- Historiography of chemistry and its philosophical implications;
- Philosophy of chemistry and chemistry education.
Submission details:
- To be considered for the December 2027 issue, submissions must be received by July 31, 2027, via the journal webpage
https://historiographyofscience.org.
- Papers should be prepared in accordance with the journal’s guidelines for authors and formatted for double-anonymised review. Manuscripts should be no more than 10,000 words, including notes, figures, tables, and bibliographic references (each image, table, or diagram counts as 300 words), and must include a title, an abstract of no more than 150 words, and five keywords.
https://periodicos.ufmg.br/index.php/transversal/about/submissions
- Notification of acceptance will be sent on October 31, 2027.
For any further information concerning this Call for Papers, please contact:
Luciana Zaterka – Federal University of ABC
Email: luciana.zaterka@ufabc.edu.br
Ronei Clécio Mocellin – Federal University of Paraná
Email: roneimocellin@ufpr.br
For any further information concerning this Journal, please contact:
Mauro L. Condé – Federal University of Minas Gerais
Email: mauroconde@ufmg.br
Fábio R. Leite – Federal University of São João del-Rei
Email: frleite@ufsj.edu.br







