NOT-AT-ISSUE CONTENT IN THE REFLEXIVE-REFERENTIAL THEORY
Keywords:
Content, Reference, Reflexivity, Presupposition, Not-at-issue contentAbstract
The Reflexive-Referential Theory is a multi-content approach to utterance interpretation. Its main proponent, John Perry, assumes that utterances of sentences with singular terms express several contents, depending on how their utterers and interpreters harness information from the situations in which they are produced. However, the theory says little to nothing about implied content, like presuppositions. Here, I discuss the possibility of including presuppositions, defined in terms of the concept of not-at-issue content, in this view. I begin with a brief characterization of the Reflexive-Referential theory in what regards its theoretical motivations and main thesis, followed by a study case of presuppositional not-at-issue content associated to a specific class of singular terms, proper names. To conclude, I ponder over a few consequences of this overall project of theoretical expansion.
References
ABBOTT, B. “Presuppositions as non-assertions”. Journal of Pragmatics, Vol. 32, Nr.10, pp.1419–1437, 2000.
_______. “Issues in the semantics and pragmatics of definite descriptions in English”. In: GUNDEL, J. K., HEDBERG, N. (eds.). Reference: Interdisciplinary Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008, pp. 61-72.
BEALER, G. “Quality and Concept”. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1982.
_______. “A Solution to Frege’s Puzzle”. Philosophical Perspectives, Vol. 7, Language and Logic, pp. 17-60, 1993.
BEAVER, D. “The kinematics of presupposition”. In: DEKKER, P., STOCKHOF, M. (eds.) Proceedings of the Eighth Amsterdam Colloquium. Amsterdam: ILLC, University of Amsterdam, 1992. pp. 17-36.
CAPPELEN, H.; LEPORE, E. “The myth of unarticulated constituents”. In: O’ROURKE, M., WASHINGTON, C. (eds.). Situating semantics: Essays on the philosophy of John Perry. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2007. pp. 199-214.
CLARK, H. H., WILKES-GIBBS, D. “Referring as a collaborative process”. Cognition, Vol. 22, Nr. 1, pp.1-39, 1986.
CLARK, H. H. “Arenas of language use”. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992.
CRIMMINS, M. “Talk About Beliefs”. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1992.
FRIEND, S. “Believing in stories”. In: CURRIE, GM KIERAN, M., MESKIN, A., ROBSON, J. (eds.) Aesthetics and the Sciences of Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014. pp. 227-248.
GARCIA-CARPINTERO, M. “Token-Reflexivity and Indirect Discourse”. In: HINTIKKA, A., NEVILLE, R., SOSA, E., OLSON, A. (eds.) The Proceedings of the Twentieth World Congress of Philosophy. Bowling Green, Ohio: Philosophy Documentation Center, 2000. pp. 37-56.
GRICE, H. P. “Presupposition and conversational implicature”. In: COLE, P (ed.) Radical Pragmatics. New York: Academic Press, 1981. pp. 183-198.
HORN, L. “Toward a Fregean Pragmatics: Voraussetzung, Nebengedanke, Audeutung”. In: KECSKES, I., HORN, L. (eds.) Explorations in Pragmatics: Linguistic, Cognitive and Intercultural Aspects. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 2007. pp. 39-72.
KAPLAN, D. Demonstratives. In: ALMOG, J., PERRY, J., WETTSTEIN, H. (eds.) Themes from Kaplan. Oxford University Press, 1989. pp. 481-563.
KARTTUNEN, L. “Implicative verbs”. Language, Vol. 47, Nr. 2, pp. 340-358, 1971a.
__________. “Some Observations on Factivity”. Papers in Linguistics, Vol. 4, Nr. 1, pp. 55-69, 1971b.
__________. “Presuppositions of Compound Sentences”. Linguistic Inquiry, Vol. 4, Nr. 2, pp. 167-193, 1973.
__________. “Presuppositions and Linguistic Context”. Theoretical Linguistics, Vol. 1, Nr. 1-3, pp. 181-194, 1974.
KEMPSON, R. “Presupposition and the Delimitation of Semantics”. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press, 1975.
KORTA, K., PERRY, J. “Critical pragmatics: An inquiry into reference and communication”. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
KRIPKE, Saul A. “Naming and necessity”. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1980.
LEWIS, D. “Scorekeeping in a language game”. Journal of Philosophical Logic, Vol. 8, Nr. 1, pp. 339-359, 1979.
MAIER, E. “Proper names and indexicals trigger rigid presuppositions”. Journal of semantics, Vol. 26, Nr. 3, pp. 253-315, 2009.
MARTI, G. “The essence of genuine reference”. Journal of Philosophical Logic, Vol. 24, Nr. 3, pp. 275-289, 1995.
MICHAELSON, R., REIMER, M. “Reference”. In: ZALTA, N. (ed.) The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (spring 2019 edition). Accessed on July, 2019.
O’ROURKE, M., WASHIGNTON, C. “Situating Semantics: Essays on the Philosophy of John Perry”. Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 2007.
PERRY, J. “The problem of the essential indexical and other essays”. Palo Alto: CSLI Publications, 2000.
__________. “Reference and reflexivity”. Palo Alto: CSLI Publications, 2001.
RECANATI, F. “Unarticulated constituents”. Linguistics and Philosophy, Vol. 25, Nr. 3, pp. 299-345, 2002.
ROBERTS, C. “Information Structure in Discourse: Towards an Integrated Formal Theory of Pragmatics”. In: YOON, J., KATHOL, A (eds.) OSU Working Papers in Linguistics No. 49: Papers in Semantics. The Ohio State University. Updated version of 1998 at: http://www.ling.ohiostate.edu/~croberts, 1996.
________. “Uniqueness in Definite noun phrases”. Linguistics and Philosophy, Vol. 26, Nr. 3, pp. 287-350, 2003.
________. “Information structure: Afterword”. Semantics and Pragmatics, Vol. 5, Nr. 7, pp.1-19, 2012.
________. “Accommodation in a Language game”. In: LOEWER, B., SCHAFFER, J. (eds.) A Companion to David Lewis. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell, 2015. pp. 345-366.
ROBERTS, C; SIMONS, M.; BEAVER, D., TONHAUSER, J. “Presupposition, conventional implicature, and beyond: a unified account of projection”. In: KLINEDIST, N., ROTHSCHILD, D. (eds.). Proceedings of the ESSLLI 2009 Workshop New Directions in the Theory of Presupposition, Bourdeaux, 2009. pp. 1-15.
SENNET, A. “Unarticulated constituents and propositional Structure”. Mind and language, Vol. 26, Nr. 4, pp. 412-435, 2011.
SIMONS, M. “Presupposition and relevance”. In: SZABÓ, Z. G. (ed.). Semantics vs. Pragmatics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005. pp. 329-355.
SIMONS, M., TONHAUSER, J., ROBERTS, C., BEAVER, D. “What projects and why”. In: LI, NAN, LUTZ, D. Semantics and linguistic theory (SALT) 20. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications, 2010. pp. 309-327.
SOAMES, S. “Presupposition”. In: GABBAY, D. M., GUENTHENER, F. Handbook of philosophical logic. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic, 1989. pp. 553-616.
STALNAKER, R. “Presuppositions”. Journal of Philosophical Logic, Vol. 2, Nr. 4, pp. 447-457, 1973.
__________. “Pragmatic Presuppositions”. In: STALNAKER, R. (ed.). Context and Content. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1974. pp. 47-62.
__________. “Common Ground”. Linguistics and Philosophy, Vol. 25, Nr. 5-6, pp. 701-721, 2002.
__________. “Context”. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.
STRAWSON, P. F. “On referring”. Mind, Vol. 59, Nr. 235, pp. 320-344, 1950.
TAYLOR, K. “Meaning, reference and cognitive significance”. Mind & language, Vol. 10, Nr. 1‐2, pp. 129-180, 1995.
__________. “Names as devices of Explicit co-reference”. Erkenntnis, Vol. 80, Nr. 2, pp. 235-262, 2015.
VAN DER SANDT, R. “Presupposition projection as anaphora resolution”. Journal of semantics, Vol. 9, Nr. 4, pp. 333-377, 1992.
VON FINTEL, K. “Would you believe it? The king of France is back! Presuppositions and truth-value intuitions”. In: REIMER, M., BEZUIDENHOUT, A. Descriptions and Beyond. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004. pp. 269-296.
WALTON, K. “Mimesis as make-believe: On the foundations of the representational arts.” Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1990.
WETTSTEIN, H. “Has Semantics Rested on a Mistake?”. Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 83, Nr. 4, pp. 185-209, 1986.
WILSON, D. “Presupposition and Non-truth-conditional Semantics”. Cambridge: Academic Press, 1975.
XIANG, M., GROVE, J., GIANNAKIDOU, A. Dependency-dependent interference: NPI interference, agreement attraction, and global pragmatic inferences. Frontiers in psychology, 2013. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2013.00708.
