The assessment of trumpet´s instrumental performance by teachers

issues and challenges

Authors

  • Maria Clara Costa School of Health Technologies of the Polytechnic Institute of Porto (Portugal)
  • Jaime Filipe Barbosa Coimbra Music Conservatory (Portugal)

Keywords:

Evaluation, Musical performance, Swanwick´s Spiral Theory of the Musical Development, Dimensions of musical evaluation used by SWANWICK e TILLMAN

Abstract

A group of Trumpet´s teachers was invited to assess the instrumental performance of two students. Initially, the evaluation of the performance of the two students was held freely (without theoretical frameworks or specific instruments) and then based on the Scale of Evaluation of Musical Execution, which was based on Swanwick’s theory. The main objective of this research is to contrast the assessments done by Trumpet´s teachers, based on Scale of Evaluation of the Musical Execution (COSTA e BARBOSA, 2010), with the free assessments (without references) carried out by the same group of teachers. By comparing the two forms of evaluation, we verify the inconsistency of the assessments and judgments in respect to the performance of the students.

Author Biographies

  • Maria Clara Costa, School of Health Technologies of the Polytechnic Institute of Porto (Portugal)

    Maria Clara Pereira Fernandes Costa has a degree in Psychology from the University of Minho. In 2000 she presented her Master's thesis at the same institution in the area of School Psychology. She is currently preparing her PhD application in Psychology at the University of Aveiro. Since 1999 he has been working as a teacher in higher education, having collaborated with the University of Minho and the Catholic University. Currently he is teaching at the School of Education of Fafe and at the School of Health Technologies of the Polytechnic Institute of Porto. He has oriented theses and research projects subordinated to the analysis of the teaching-learning process in a psychological perspective. She has published in the area of Educational Psychology.

  • Jaime Filipe Barbosa, Coimbra Music Conservatory (Portugal)

    Jaime Filipe Barbosa carried out his musical studies at the Conservatório de Música do Porto, where he completed in 1993 the Complete Trumpet Course (Pedagogical Exp. 1971). More recently, in 2007, he finished his degree in Educational Orientation at Escola Superior de Educação de Fafe. As a trumpet player, he collaborates with institutions like the Porto National Orchestra and the Philharmonic Orchestra of Beiras, among others, and performs regularly in chamber music groups. He is, since 1995, trumpet teacher in Coimbra Music Conservatory and in Oliveira de Azeméis Music Academy.

References

ANDRADE, Margareth. A avaliação em execução musical. Estudo sobre critérios utilizados por regentes de grupos corais escolares. Paraná: UFPR, 2001.

ASMUS, Edward. Music Assessment Concepts. Music Educators Journal, v.86, n.2, 1999, p.19-24.

COSTA, Maria Manuela. O valor da música na educação na perspetiva de Keith Swanwick. Lisboa: Instituto de Educação da Universidade de Lisboa, 2010 (Dissertação de Mestrado).

COSTA, Clara; BARBOSA, Jaime. Avaliação na Música: questões e dificuldades. Fafe: Escola Superior de Educação de Fafe, 2010 (Tese do Curso de Formação Complementar em Orientação Educativa).

DEL BEN, Luciana. Avaliação da aprendizagem musical dos alunos: reflexões a partir das conceções de três professoras de música do ensino fundamental. In: HENTSCHKE e SOUZA (Orgs). Avaliação em Música: reflexões e práticas. São Paulo: Editora Moderna, 2003, p.29-40.

ELLIOTT, David. Music Matters, a new philosophy of music education. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995.

FRANÇA, Cecilia Cavalieri. Composing, performing and audience-listening as symmetrical indicators of musical understanding. University of London Institute of Education,1998 (Tese de Doutoramento, PhD).

FRANÇA, Cecília Cavalieri. Possibilidades de aplicação do modelo espiral de desenvolvimento musical como critério de avaliação no vestibular da escola de música da UFMG. Opus, Belo Horizonte: UFMG, v.7, 2000b, www.musica.ufmg.br/anppom/opus. Acesso em: 3 de abril,2012.

FRANCA, Cecília Cavalieri. Dizer o indizível: considerações sobre a avaliação da performance instrumental de vestibulandos e graduandos em música. PER Musi, n.10, 2004, p.31-48.

FRANÇA, Cecilia Cavalieri; SWANWICK, Keith. Composição, apreciação e performance na educação musical: teoria, pesquisa e prática. Em Pauta, v 13, nº 21, 2002, p.5-41.

HARGREAVES, David. The developmental psychology of music: Scope and aims. In: G. SPRUCE (Ed). Teaching Music. London: Routledge, 1996.

JOHNSON, Peter. Performance as Experience: the problem of assessment criteria. British Journal of Music Education, v.14, n.3, 1997, p.271-282.

SANTOS, Cynthia. Avaliação da Execução Musical: A Concepção Teórico-prática dos Professores de Piano. In: HENTSCHKE, L. e SOUZA, J. (Orgs), Avaliação em música: reflexões e práticas. São Paulo: Moderna. 2003. cap 3, p.41-50.

SLOBODA, John. Music performance: expression and the development of excellence. In: R. AIELLO (Ed.), Musical perceptions New York: Oxford University Press,1994, p.152-172.

STAVRIDES, Michael. The Interaction of Audience-Listening and Composing: A Study in Cyprus Schools, Unpublished PhD, University of London, Institute of Education,1995.

SWANWICK, Keith. Music Mind and Education. London: Routledge,1988.

_______________.Musical Knowledge. Intuition analysis and music education. London: Routledge, 1994.

_______________.Teaching Music Musically. New York: Routledge, 2012.

SWANWICK, Keith; TILLMAN, June. The sequence of musical development: a study of children’s composition. British Journal of Music Education, v. 3, n.3, 1986, p.305-339.

SWANWICK, Keith; RUNFOLA, Maria. Developmental characteristics of music learners. In R. COLWELL E C. RICHARDSON (Eds.). The new handbook of research on music teaching and learning. MENC. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002, p.373-397.

TOURINHO, Cristina. Relações entre os Critérios de avaliação do professor de Violão e uma teoria de Desenvolvimento Musical. Salvador, 2001 (Tese de Doutoramento).

TOURINHO, Cristina; OLIVEIRA, Alda. Avaliação da Performance Musical. In: HENTSCHKE e. SOUZA (Orgs), Avaliação em música: reflexões e práticas. São Paulo: Moderna. 2003, p.13-28.

Downloads

Published

2015-06-10

Issue

No. 31 (2015): General Topics

Section

Articles in Portuguese/Spanish

License

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Licença Creative Commons
Except where otherwise noted, contents on this site are licensed under a  Creative Commons - Atribuição 4.0 Internacional.

How to Cite

“The Assessment of trumpet´s Instrumental Performance by Teachers: Issues and Challenges”. 2015. Per Musi, no. 31 (June): 1-15. https://periodicos.ufmg.br/index.php/permusi/article/view/38791.

Similar Articles

21-30 of 93

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.